Used Ball Mill Selection Guide: Choosing Diameter, Overflow vs. Grate Discharge & Bearing Type from Chinese Surplus
How to properly size a used ball mill (Φ1.5m to Φ3.6m), evaluate rolling bearings vs. sliding bearings, pass ultrasonic NDT checks on shells and bull gears, and avoid flat-rack shipping surprises.
Select a grate-discharge ball mill (MQG) for coarser primary grinding (0.15–0.6 mm) and higher throughput with minimal over-grinding, or an overflow ball mill (MQY) for fine grinding (P80 74 µm or finer) ahead of CIL gold leaching or sulfide flotation. When sourcing used Chinese mills, prioritize spherical roller main bearings over legacy babbitt sliding bearings to cut power draw by 15%–25%, and plan 40FR Flat Rack or breakbulk logistics for any mill diameter ≥ 2.4 meters.
In This Guide
Overflow (MQY) vs. Grate-Discharge (MQG) Used Ball Mill Selection Matrix
| Parameter | Grate-Discharge Ball Mill (MQG) | Overflow Ball Mill (MQY) |
|---|---|---|
| Target Product Fineness | Coarser grind (0.15 – 0.6 mm) | Fine grind (≤ 0.074 mm / 200 mesh) |
| Typical Process Role | Gravity gold, iron magnetic, 1st-stage grinding | Gold CIL/CIP, copper/lithium flotation, 2nd-stage |
| Over-Grinding Risk | Low (fast slurry discharge through grate) | Moderate (higher slurry pool level) |
| Maintenance Complexity | Requires periodic grate plate inspection/replacement | Simpler discharge end; lower wear-part count |
1. Matching Mill Diameter to Bond Work Index & Daily Tonnage
Ball mill sizing is governed by ore hardness (Bond Work Index, Wi), feed size (F80—ideally crushed below 12–15 mm), and target grind liberation size (P80). In practical terms, a Φ1500×3000 mm mill handles 50–100 TPD, a Φ1830×4500 mm handles 120–220 TPD, a Φ2400×4500 mm handles 300–550 TPD, and a Φ3200×4500 mm serves 800–1,400 TPD circuits. Always pair used mills with properly sized spiral classifiers or hydrocyclone clusters to close the grinding loop.
2. Why Main Bearing Design Is a Huge Hidden Value Lever in China
Older Chinese ball mills used hydrodynamic babbitt sliding bearings that require continuous high/low-pressure oil stations and consume higher starting torque. Newer-generation Chinese stationary mills adopted heavy-duty double-row spherical roller bearings, cutting electricity consumption by 15%–25% and drastically simplifying lubrication on remote African or Southeast Asian mine sites. Checking bearing type during selection pays for itself in fuel savings within months.
3. Four Non-Negotiable Mechanical Checks Before Buying a Used Ball Mill
First, run ultrasonic thickness and crack inspection on the cylindrical shell plate and longitudinal weld seams. Second, measure end trunnion journal concentricity and NDT-check the hollow shaft fillets where stress concentrates. Third, inspect the bull gear tooth flanks—many industrial ring gears are symmetrical and can be flipped 180 degrees during refurbishment if one side shows wear. Fourth, inspect the heavy gearbox reducer teeth and bearing seats.
4. Containerization vs. 40FR Flat Rack & Breakbulk Thresholds
A standard 40HQ container has an internal door width of roughly 2.34 meters. Once a ball mill shell reaches Φ2.4m (outer diameter ~2.6–2.75m with flanges), it cannot fit inside a standard box container. Properly planning shell/trunnion disassembly for 40FR Flat Racks or breakbulk vessels—and loading new rubber or Cr-Mo alloy liners plus initial grinding balls in the companion 40HQ/20GP box—keeps landed cost tightly controlled.
Mills above 280–315 kW in China commonly run on 6kV or 10kV high-voltage motors. If your remote mine relies on 400V/440V diesel generators, we advise early during selection on step-up transformers, low-voltage high-power VFD conversions, or soft-start drive retrofits.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should we keep used steel liners inside a used ball mill when shipping?
Only if remaining liner thickness exceeds 70% and matches your target grind profile. In most export orders, removing worn liners cuts dead shipping weight, allows full internal shell NDT inspection, and lets you install brand-new rubber or high-chrome alloy liners at commissioning.